In short: A used Callaway Hickory Stick putter is worth about $74, our target price, checked Oct 31, 2026. $50 or less is a great buy and anything up to $74 is a good buy; over $97 it’s overpriced. It costs less than 96% of the 196 used putters we’ve priced; the typical one is about $185.
What to pay for a used Callaway Hickory Stick putter
$50 or less
32% or more under the target.
$51–$74
At or under the target.
Over $97
$75–$97 is a fair price; offer near $74.
Count the shipping. Hold the landed price, the club plus shipping, up against these numbers.
Selling one? List it at or just under the target, $74, and it should move fast. How to price and list a used club
Buying guide: The best used putters to buy in 2026, by budget
Target price history
Down 3% since Sep 23, 2026, from $76 to $74.
| Checked | Used target |
|---|---|
| Oct 31, 2026 | $74 |
| Sep 23, 2026 | $76 |
Other Callaway putters, priced
| Club | Year | Used target | vs this one |
|---|---|---|---|
| Callaway Big Bertha Warbird putter | — | $68 | −$6 |
| Callaway i-Trax putter | — | $129 | +$55 |
| Callaway S2H2 M2 putter | — | $41 | −$33 |
| Callaway Tuttle putter | — | $30 | −$44 |
More to check
- Arnold Palmer putter
- Big Bertha Blade putter
- Bobby Jones-2 putter
- Bobby Jones-3 putter
- Bobby Jones-7 putter
- Carlsbad Palmoar putter
- Carlsbad Rutherford putter
- S2H2 M1 putter
Other brands at about the same price
Used putters from other brands with targets within 20% of this one.
| Club | Year | Used target | vs this one |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ping Shea putter | 2021 | $80 | +$6 |
| Odyssey White Hot 1 putter | — | $78 | +$4 |
| Wilson Staff Infinite Windy City putter | 2024 | $75 | +$1 |
| Cleveland Huntington Beach 4 putter | — | $65 | −$9 |
Specs to match
- Type
- Putter
Length matters: pick one close to what you use now (most are 33 to 35 inches). Check the head style and hosel, the grip, and whether the headcover is included; on collector putters it adds real value.
Questions
How much is a used Hickory Stick putter worth?
A used Callaway Hickory Stick putter is worth about $74: that’s our algorithm’s target price, checked Oct 31, 2026. Under that is a good buy; over it, make an offer near the target or keep looking.
What’s a good price for a used Callaway Hickory Stick putter?
Anything at or under $74 is a good buy, and $50 or less is a great one. Over $97 is overpriced. Those lines come from our algorithm’s target price, checked Oct 31, 2026; hold them up against the price plus shipping.
What should I list my used Hickory Stick putter for?
At or just under the target, $74. That’s roughly what buyers pay for one, so it should sell quickly; list it well above and expect offers near the target.
Where can I buy a used Callaway Hickory Stick putter?
When we last checked there were 40 live options near the target, from $35 with shipping included. ClubChecks lists every one, cheapest first, and tags each as under or over the target.
Is the price of a used Callaway Hickory Stick putter going up or down?
Down 3% since Sep 23, 2026, from $76 to $74. That’s our algorithm’s target price, which it checks again regularly.
What should I check before buying a used putter?
Length matters: pick one close to what you use now (most are 33 to 35 inches). Check the head style and hosel, the grip, and whether the headcover is included; on collector putters it adds real value.